Why Writers Should Read Crap



All writers get the same advice. Read the great writers; study the great works. Learn how seasoned, professional, and successful authors get the job done. All true, but I maintain that it’s also crucial for writers to read crap to learn what not to do.

How do you know what’s crap? It’s not a book that didn’t sell well, although that sometimes may be a clue. It’s not one that received bad reviews either. Some of the world’s greatest books have garnered negative comments from critics. Crappy writing is like the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling on what constitutes pornography. You know it when you see it. And you know it because you’ve mainly been reading good writing.

More concrete indications of bad prose are sections that make you go “Huh?” or that make you laugh because they’re so ridiculous even though the author meant it to be serious. It’s prose that’s boring, even if you can’t articulate why your mind is wandering. Crappy writing just doesn’t sound right to your ear.

Other bad writing signs include no variation in sentence length, too much telling instead of showing, overshowing, no drama, no emotion, backstories that are too long, unnecessary detail, and on and on. I’m not talking about mechanical problems with grammar or lapses in POV or tense but simple, bad freakin’ writing.

Here are some examples from real self-published books. I have changed the wording slightly so as not to embarrass the author.

Sample: “We have to move quickly, pal. We already have an elite team on its way to Nigeria to rescue the pilot. But these paratroopers are going to stand out like chocolate chips in vanilla ice cream without some assistance on the ground. I need someone to be there to meet them or they’ll be minced meat.”

What did you learn? It’s trite and boring because the writing is obvious, full of clichés and the “chocolate chips?” Make it stop. Send the elite team? Why would you send the non-elite team? And yes, we do have to move quickly because moving slowly would. . .well. . .you know.

Sample: “Hi, Bob! Sorry, I’m so late! She awkwardly returned the kiss, her kitbag bumping against her knees and her laptop bag hanging from one shoulder.”

What did you learn? First, cut the exclamation points. You’re allowed only a few per book, and they should be reserved for “Look out!” like when a rock is falling on a character’s  head. Show me how she “awkwardly returned the kiss”; don’t tell me. Last, who cares about her kitbag hitting her knee or that her laptop bag hung from one shoulder? (Can a laptop even hang from two shoulders?) What does that sentence add? Mood, ambience, emotion, anything? Nothing! (I used the exclamation point because I felt that I was in danger.)

I was going to offer one more example, but this exercise made me a little sick to my stomach, so I’ll stop here.

Again, why read crap? So you know what not to do. You’re learning from others’ mistakes without people like me making fun of you in this blog. We are all guilty of lapses in writing judgment. I have made the same mistakes that I detailed here (which I seek and destroy in the rewriting process) especially because I come from the non-fiction side of writing books where some of these transgressions–like telling instead of showing–is not only acceptable but encouraged. In fact, one of the tenets of non-fiction writing is “tell people what you’re going to tell them; tell them; then tell them what you told them.” Do this in fiction and you’re inviting readers to pummel you.

My advice is to read some crap every once in a while but not too much. And don’t pay for it. Please. Read the free samples on Amazon. You only have to read (thankfully) the first few pages to learn their abject lessons.



Guest post contributed by Larry Kahaner. He is the author of more than a dozen non-fiction books and has just finished the draft to his first thriller. Check out more of his posts at his blog.

Would you like two free audio books? Begin your 30-day free trial at Audible.com and receive two free audio books and 30% off additional audiobook purchases. You keep your two free books even if you later cancel.


24 thoughts on “Why Writers Should Read Crap”

  1. Ha ha. This is funny but what is sad is that I’m sure I’ve written some crap myself. Lesson: Watch out. You might be writing crap. I guess that’s why we need objective readers to honestly critique our writing.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Haha! I was once asked to review a book that sadly I had to return to the author and decline. During a very early “meant to be hot and steamy sex scene” I started laughing hysterically. I do believe the writer had some sort of unaddressed clothing and general textile fetish! She went on and on for 3 pages describing every fiber of fabric comprising the clothing, toss pillows and carpet in the setting. Whew!

    Liked by 3 people

  3. Good post. I’d also recommend an add-on to this entry, the book How Not to Write a Novel by Howard Mittelmark and Sandra Newman. Sort of the same premise — learn about mistakes and utterly bad writing so that you may never be guilty of doing the same.


  4. “Gotta hike, pal.” I think a big part of crappy writing is not having researched. If you’re writing about Army Rangers going to Africa, you need to know something about them, such as how they normally talk to each other. Which might mean interviewing somebody military who went to Somalia in 1993. Probably difficult to secure, especially with a former Ranger: Veterans don’t often like discussing theatre experiences with civilians. Which is why good novels often take years to produce.


  5. So true. I just finished a fantasy book with great ideas, predictable story, and mediocre writing. Not as bad as your examples, thankfully, but enough to understand and agree with your point. Every read is a potential learning experience.


  6. Poor, unedited examples for sure, but why do you single out self-published books. I’ve read plenty of junk in well-known, commercially published books, too.


  7. Reblogged this on quirkywritingcorner and commented:
    My first novel, “Dana’s Dilemma”, is crap if you want an example of what not to do. I thought it was better when I wrote it, but I plan to add a bit to it and have it republished after my next novel comes out. The publisher chose to print it in 9 font which did not help sales. Great cover at least.


  8. Good advice, we need to read some horrible writing to analyze what’s wrong with it. Examples are always helpful so we remember what not to do.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.