The Benefits of Joining a Writers Group


by Cynthia Hilston

There it was for probably the hundredth time on the sign outside my local library: writers group, meeting 8/18 2-4:00 PM.  Okay, maybe not the hundredth time, but how many times did I drive past the library, which is about two point five miles from my house, and see that group advertised and not do a darn thing?  The sign was one of those LED types that showed all the happenings at the library, from book discussion groups to story times for children.  And my library had a writers group.

Of course, every time I saw that sign, I wondered, What do they do at those meetings?  Do they just sit there and write?  Do writing exercises?  Or do they read each other’s work while there and comment on it?

I imagined a small group, maybe four people tops, sitting around a table with pens in hand and paper in front of them.  These folks were nameless and faceless and voiceless.  Strangers.  I couldn’t really believe that there were actually other people in my own city who were writers like me!

I’d been writing for over a year last August.  I was content with my progress at creating a finished book and self-publishing it, but I’d had to ask several friends to read it and edit for me.  Looking back, I feel like I was pulling teeth in some regards, because only about half of them got back to me, and I didn’t wish to push them into doing something they may not have wanted to do in the first place — except that they probably would have felt guilty had they said no to reading my first draft.

While I was grateful to that group of friends, I knew that to ask my friends again for help of such a magnitude would be too much.  I was writing two more books, and let’s be honest — most people aren’t writers and editors.

So I thought, Why not give this mysterious writers group a try?

On August 18, 2016, I approached the library with a mixed feeling of nervous energy and excitement.  Every footstep carried me closer to the light brick building I had known and visited plenty of times in the thirteen years of living here.  But this time was different.  I held tightly in my grip the first chapter of my current work in progress, thinking I needed to bring something along.

I entered the library and asked the lady behind the circulation desk where the writers group met.  She directed me to a meeting room near the back of the building, past the computers.  When I stepped into the room, at least ten people of all ages (well, thirty and up) were seated around the table and all looked at me at the same time.  The chair at the head of the long table was unoccupied, so I took a seat and offered a smile.

The woman to my left and the man to my right immediately introduced themselves to me, and a minute later, the man who ran the group (and worked at the library) told me his name (let’s call him Jack) and asked me to tell them a little about myself.  I was at ease in this group, for they were welcoming and pleasant.  And I wasn’t the only newbie that day.  Another woman (let’s call her Kate) about the same age as me (mid-thirties) was there for the first time.  Kate smiled at me across the table.  I was at home.

I sat there for the next two hours and got a handle on how the group functioned.  Everyone present had read everyone else’s work and had made comments on the content and suggestions for grammatical or punctuation changes.  As they went around the table, whoever was next in the lineup got their turn to have their work critiqued by the others.  Not everyone spoke, but most did.  I could tell most of these folks had been meeting for a while.  Their easygoing manner was inviting.  There was plenty of humor.  No one was offensive or rude.  It was like stepping into a group of good friends who were hanging out and enjoying some good food and drinks.

At the end, Jack asked me what I thought and if I’d like to come back.  “Yes!” I said.  I gave him my email address, and he explained how the group worked: They met every two weeks.  I needed to send him up to ten pages of my stuff before the first week was up, so he could then send out everyone’s stuff about a week before the next meeting, giving us all enough time to read and comment.

I was so enthusiastic that I sent him my chapter the very next day, even though I had a week to do so!  And so began the tradition that’s continued for almost a year.

People have come and gone from the group over the last several months, but there is a core group that keeps coming.  I have had the pleasure of reading what I consider good stories from a variety of genres from these folks: regular and cozy mysteries, romance, horror, nonfiction, short stories, sci-fi, and more.  There have been a few recent additions to the group who have become core as well, and it’s been amazing to see how the dynamic has stayed positive and inviting, with the humor never far away, since I joined.

What’s funny is that some people will shy away from joining groups like this out of fear.  If you’re a writer, maybe you just write for yourself, and that’s fine.  There are, however, many writers who want to get their stuff out there.  They write for their own pleasure and to share it with other people.  To allow fear of what others might say about your work is debilitating.  If you are serious about publishing your work, others will eventually read it…at least I would assume that’s what you want if you’re publishing it!

There have been times when what I submitted to the writers group needed some work, sometimes quite a bit of work.  I have gotten tough to swallow feedback, especially when it’s right in the moment.  Let’s face it — our writing is kind of like our baby, our kid.  We sort of fall in love with it (at least some of us do), and it’s hard to hear someone rip it apart.  Okay, that was harsh.  I have not had my stuff ripped to shreds.  No one in the group has ever discouraged me from writing or said I was wasting my time.  No one name calls or says that the work of another is only good for wiping someone’s backside.

Constructive criticism is meant to build up.  It may be tough to take, but swallow it down and let it digest a bit.  Realize that not everything you write it going to be stellar.  Some of it’s downright crap.  And that’s okay.  Because you know what?

You and I, we work at it again and again.  And come back better and stronger for it.  I am extremely and deeply grateful for my writers group.  I have told them this a few times, and I hope they believe it.

I recently finished a whole manuscript with them.  Ten months of edits on that baby have improved the story tremendously, and without this group of amazing people, I wouldn’t have been able to have the finished product I do.

If you’ve been looking for a writers group, check out your local library.  If your library doesn’t have one, maybe there’s one in the next city over or in the county.  In this digital age, there’s no excuse not to pop online and do a search.  If you’re still out of luck, perhaps suggest to someone at the library that they start a group…or even offer to run it if they don’t have someone for the job.  If you know at least a couple of other writers who are looking for a group like this and they’re local, start a group that meets in your homes, a coffee shops, or wherever works for you.  But make the commitment to meet regularly.  Have a routine, a schedule.  Hold each other accountable to it.

If none of that works, there are plenty of groups online.  It’s not as great as face-to-face contact, but it’s better than nothing.  Facebook has loads of groups for writers, but I recommend 10 Minute Novelists.  This isn’t a group to share your story directly, but every Tuesday is Buddy Day, and you can ask for someone to read your story and edit, often in exchange for doing the same for them.  Don’t expect people to line up to read your stuff if you aren’t willing to give back.

Besides the invaluable feedback on my stories I’ve gotten from my writers group, I have made friends with them.  There have been times when the subject matter of a story has triggered something for someone in the group, and real life stories have been shared in that meeting room.  Stories of loss and heartache.  Tears have been shed.  Hugs given.  Our hearts bared.

We’re writers.  We write about our deepest fears, desires, and our heart’s song, so why wouldn’t we also express those thoughts face-to-face?  That sort of genuine interaction isn’t easily come by.

Friendship.  Constructive criticism.  People reading your story.  Improving your writing.

What’s not to love?  I’d say it’s a no-brainer.  Go join a writers group!




Cynthia Hilston is the author of Hannah’s Rainbow: Every Color Beautiful, based loosely off her late grandma’s life.  She is a mommy of three young-ins, an orange kitty, and more stories on the way.  Follow her blog at Cynthia Hilston, Author or find her on Facebook.

34 thoughts on “The Benefits of Joining a Writers Group

  1. I heartily agree with your feelings about joining a writing critique group. I was prompted to finally do so when I moved to a new city. Finding it to be so motivating, I then looked into writing groups specifically aimed at writing for kids and found out there wasn’t one locally. I contacted SCBWI (Society of Children’s Book Writers and Illustrators), and I now lead one. The meetings with both groups are high on my list of favorite activities each month!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. That sounds like what a writing group ‘should’ be like.

    I’ve never encountered one like that – if I had, I probably wouldn’t avoid them at all cost – but it’s nice to know that they’re out there, these mysterious entities where being a writer is actually a good thing.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Your group sounds great, Cynthia. I haven’t found one that gelled like that. My last group had some real characters. I could write a book. Thievery, negativity, and fear! Still, I’m always on the lookout for that perfect balance. Thanks for letting me know it exists.

    Liked by 2 people

  4. That is inspiring. I am usually that guy as well. I’ll drive by reading a sign thinking “hmm, I wonder what that is” – only to never pursue it. A good group of friends is hard to come by, let alone a solid group of writers. I’m going to make a more conscious effort to find a group to inspire me to keep writing my book and building my freelance business =). Thanks for sharing.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. Thank you for these much needed words of encouragement. There was a time when I thought I was meeting a different group of writers on separate occasions and it turned out to be more of a sales meeting of sorts.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Wow, thanks to all who have liked or commented. I am glad my post has inspired some. For those who haven’t had good experiences with a group, I am sorry to hear it. I encourage you to keep looking or start your own. I feel these groups can be invaluable.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I’ve never managed to stick with a writers group. Equal parts difficulty in attending and just not wanting to read that many other people’s works. Kudos to you for putting in the hard work and sticking with it.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. I want to emphasize a point in the post: being a member of a writers’ group is a commitment to your fellow group members. As Cyndi points out, when someone grants you the time it takes to read and respond seriously to your work, that’s a huge gift. You owe them the same. I belong to both a face-to-face group and an online group, and reciprocity is core. Don’t show up only when you have something you want critiqued. Show up as often as you can and contribute. Learning to give and take critique well is hard, but after all, again as Cyndi says, you’re writing for readers, and these are the readers who have made the commitment to actually read what you wrote. Be glad for them!

    Liked by 1 person

  9. Reblogged this on Just Can't Help Writing and commented:
    As a member of a long-running face-to-face group and now an active online group, I can attest that good groups exist. I spend far too many years writing in isolation; never again. Maybe I don’t like every response; maybe sometimes I’m disheartened. But I’d rather be disheartened now when I can figure out what to do about the problem than when I get that “we’re not the right agency for this project” form letter with NO feedback as to why.

    I’ve posted about my group several times, and I did a series on the founding of our group, the Green River Writers, and its leader, Mary (Ernie) O’Dell, here in Louisville. And I just posted the 2017 Contest brochure for this year’s Green River Writers contest! A terrific contest with low entries fees and lots of cash prizes! Check it out!


  10. Great inspiring article. Often the feeling of fear far outweighs the benefits of joining a group – until you take the plunge! To have a support unit is often invaluable – as I have learned myself!

    Liked by 1 person

  11. I have been in three writer’s groups over the past four years. One is defunct now, but I still participate in the other two. I can’t imagine my writer’s life without them. They offer so much!


  12. com/2017/08/06/the-benefits-of-joining-a-writers-mathematical group/” rel=”nofollow”>Just Can't avail Writing and commented:
    As a penis of a long-running face-to-face mathematical group and now an dynamic online mathematical group, I can testify that safe mathematical groups live.
    I’ve posted about my mathematical group several(a) times, and I did a serial on the founding of our mathematical group, the Green River Writers, and its drawing card, Mary (Ernie) O’Dell, here in Louisville.


  13. I belong to two writing groups and I often read, and get comments on, the same piece to both groups. They always offer a different perspective and help me decide how readers will react. You are so right, join a writing group and learn so much!


  14. I love the article as it puts perspective on writing. I am exploring this path in my life and have always wanted to write. Maybe one day I can publish, but it seems my interests are in articles mostly. Thank you for the encouraging words.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.